区域生态风险评价研究进展

颜磊, 许学工

地域研究与开发 ›› 2010, Vol. 29 ›› Issue (1) : 113-118,129.

PDF(758 KB)
地域研究与开发
PDF(758 KB)
地域研究与开发 ›› 2010, Vol. 29 ›› Issue (1) : 113-118,129.
生态环境研究

区域生态风险评价研究进展

  • 颜磊 ， 许学工
作者信息 +

Progress of Regional Ecological Risk Assessment

  • Yan Lei ,  Xu Xuegong
Author information +
文章历史 +

摘要

生态风险评价已进入到区域生态风险评价阶段，评价尺度的扩展反映了人类对自身生命支持系统的关注和对环境进行管理和决策的实践需要。针对区域尺度的生态风险评价，着重从评价区域类型、评价内容、范式、方法、技术、模型等层面进行综述。结果表明：区域生态风险评估的核心和关键是合理选择和表征区域生态风险源和风险受体，科学探讨和量化多风险源和多风险受体的交互作用。面向未来，区域生态风险评价应该在等级斑块动态理论框架指导下，发展一套具体的评价方法，深入进行不确定性分析，加强GIS技术和其他模型、技术的综合运用。

Abstract

Ecological Risk Assessment (ERA) is evolving. With the expansion of scale, it goes into the phase of Regional Risk Ecological Risk (RERA), which reflects the practice requirement of environment management and decision-making. Facing multi-stressors, multi-stressors and their complex interaction at regional scale, different methods, techniques and models are applied in many RERA case studies in the past 20 years. Although paradigm, framework and achievements are reached, there still have many problems in RERA, such as the upscaling from individual to region, and the uncertainly issues. For a full understanding and better future studying, this paper provides a detail literature review on RERA from perspectives of assessment area type, research context, paradigm, framework, method, technology and related model. Here, we argue that the crucial and challenge work in RERA is reasonable choosing and characterization of regional risk stressors and receptors, and quantification of the complex stressorreceptors interaction. We also suggest that future study on RERA should establish more concrete and solid method for assessment under guideline of the hierarchical patch dynamic paradigm, strength the uncertainty analysis, reinforce geographic information systems (GIS) application combined with other models and techniques, and develop towards a regional integrated ecological assessment.

关键词

区域 / 生态风险 / 生态风险评价 / 研究进展

Key words

region / ecological risk / ecological risk assessment / research progress

引用本文

EndNote

Ris (Procite)

Bibtex

导出引用
颜磊, 许学工. 区域生态风险评价研究进展[J]. 地域研究与开发, 2010, 29(1): 113-118,129
YAN Lei, Xu-Xue-Gong. Progress of Regional Ecological Risk Assessment[J]. Areal Research and Development, 2010, 29(1): 113-118,129
中图分类号： X826   

参考文献

［1］Craghan M. The Study of Human Action in the Physical Environment［J］.Physical Geography,2004,25(3):251-268.

［2］Marsh J P, Lowenthal D. Man and Nature［M］. Cambridge: the Belknap Press of Harvard University Press，1965.

［3］Miler J. Living in the Environment (影印版)［M］. 北京: 高等教育出版社，2004.

［4］Palmer M A, Bernhard E S, Chornesky E A, et al. Ecological Science and Sustainability for the 21st Century［J］.Front Ecological Environment,2005,3(1):4-11.

［5］Suter G W. Ecological Risk Assessment［M］. Boca Ration F L: Lewis Publishers，1993.

［6］U S EPA Guidelines for Ecological Risk Assessment［M］. Washington D C: Office of Water，1998.

［7］Preuss P W, Vandenberg J J, Tuxen L, et al. Risk Aassessment at the U.S.EPA: the Science behind the Assessments ［J］. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2007,13(1):41-45.

［8］U S EPA. Framework for Ecological Risk Assessment［M］. Washington D C: Risk Forum,1992.

［9］U S EPA Ecological Risk Assessment Guidance for Superfund: Process for Designing and Conducting Ecological Risk Assessment［EB/OL］.(1997-05-10)［2009-03-25］.http://www.epa.gov/oswer/riskassessment/ecorisk/pdf/appb.pdf.

［10］Landis W G. The Frontiers in Ecological Risk Assessment at Expanding Spatial and Temporal Scales［J］. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2003,9(6):1415-1421.

［11］付在毅, 许学工. 生态风险研究进展［J］.地理科学进展,2001,16(2):267-271.

［12］陈辉, 刘劲松, 曹宇, 等. 生态风险评价研究进展［J］. 生态学报, 2006,26(5):1558-1566.

［13］阳文锐, 王如松, 黄锦楼. 生态风险评价及研究进展［J］. 应用生态学报,2007,18(8):1869-1876.

［14］Hunsaker C T, Graham R L, Suter G W, et al. Regional Ecological Risk Assessment Theory and Demonstration［Z］. Oak Ridge T N: Oak Ridge National Laboratory,1989.

［15］Hunsaker C T, Graham R L, Suter G W, et al. Assessing Ecological Risk on A Regional Scale［J］. Environmental Management,1990,14(3):325-332.

［16］Suter G W. Endpoints for Regional Ecological Risk Assessments［J］. Environmental Management,1990,14(1):9-23.

［17］Walker R, Landies W G, Brown P. Development ARegional Ecological Risk Assessment: A Case Study of A Tasmanian Agriculture Catchment［J］. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2001,7(2):417-439.

［18］Obery A M, Landies W G. A Regional Multiple Stressor Risk Assessment of the Codorus Creek Watershed Applying the Relative Risk Model［J］. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2002,8(2):405-428.

［19］Leuven R S E W, Poudevinge I. Riverine Landscape Dynamics and Ecological Risk Assessment［J］. Freshwater Biology,2002,47(4):845-865.

［20］Serveiss V B, Bowen J L, Dow D, et al. Using Ecological Risk Assessment to Identify the Major Anthropogenic Stressor in the Waquoit Bay Watershed, Cape Cod, Massachusetts［J］. Environmental Management,2004,33(5):730-740.

［21］Kooistra L, Leuven R S E W, Nienhuis P H, et al. A Procedure for Incorporating Spatial Variability in Ecological Risk Assessment of Dutch River Floodplains［J］. Environmental Management,2001,28(3):359-373.

［22］Wiegers J K, Feder H M, Mortenson L S, et al. A Regional Multiplestressor Rankbased Ecological Risk Assessment for the Fjord of Port Valdez, Alaska［J］. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,1998,4(5):1152-1173.

［23］Colnar A M, Landis W G. Conceptual Model Development for Invasive Species and A Regional Risk Assessment Case Study: the European Green Crab, Carcinus Maenas, at Cherry Point, Washington, USA［J］. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2007,13(1):120-155.

［24］Xu X G, Lin H P, Fu Z Y. Probe into the Method of Regional Ecological Risk Assessment: A Case Study of Weltand in the Yellow River Delta in China［J］. Journal of Environment Management,2004,70(3):253-262.

［25］Hayes E H, Landis W G. Regional Ecological Risk Assessment of A Near Shore Marine Environment: Cherry Point W A［J］. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2004,10(2):299-325.

［26］Salihoglu G, Karaer F. Ecological Risk Assessment and Problem Formulation for Lake Ulubat, A Ramsar State in Turkey［J］. Environmental Management,2004,33(6):899- 910.

［27］Moraes R, Landis W G, Molander S. Regional Risk Assessment of A Brazilian Rain Forest Reserve［J］. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2002,8(7):1779-1803.

［28］Kienast F, Wildi O, Brzeziecki B. Potential Impact of Climate Change on Species Richness in Mountain Forests: An Ecological Risk Assessment［J］. Biological Conservation,1998,83(3):291-305.

［29］Chen H, Liu J S, Cao Y, et al. Ecological Risk Assessment of Regions along the Roadside of the QinghaiTibet Highway and Railway Based on An Artificial Neural Network［J］. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2007,13(4):900-913.

［30］Redfearn A, May M, Roberts D. Ecological Risk Assessment Methodology: A UK Case Study for Landfills［J］. Journal of the Chartered Institution of Water and Environmental Management,2004,18(3):139-145.

［31］Pereira R, Ribeiro R, Goncalves F. Plan for An Integrated Human and Environment Risk Assessment in the S. Doingos Mine Area (Portugal)［J］. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2004,10(3):543-578.

［32］Chapman P M. Introduction: Ecological Risk Assessments at Petroleumcontaminated Terrestrial Sites［J］. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2004,10(2):183-184.

［33］Louda S M, Arnett A E, Rand T A, et al. Invasiveness of Some Biological Control Insects and Adequacy of Their Ecological Risk Assessment and Regulation［J］. Conservation Biology,2003,17(1):73-82.

［34］Hope B K, Peterson J A. A Procedure for Performing Populationlevel Ecological Risk Assessments［J］. Environment Management,2000,25(3):281-289.

［35］Purucker S T, Welsh C J E, Stewart R N, et al. Use of HabitatContamination Spatial Correlation to Determine when to Perform A Spatially Explicit Ecological Risk Assessment［J］. Ecological Modeling,2007,204(1~2):180-192.

［36］Chow T E, Gaines K F, Hodgson M E, et al. Habitat and Exposure Modeling for Ecological Risk Assessment: A Case Study for the Raccoon on the Savannah River Site［J］. Ecological Modeling,2005,189(1~2):151-167.

［37］Serveiss V B. Applying Ecological Risk Principles to Watershed Assessment and Management［J］. Environmental Management,2002,29(2):145-154.

［38］Serveiss V B, Ohlson D W. Using Ecological Risk Assessment Principles in A Source Water Protection Assessment［J］. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2007,13(2):402-417.

［39］Nomura K, Yamaoka K, Okano T, et al. Risk Perception, Risktaking Attitude, and Hypothetical Behavior of Active Volvano Tourists［J］. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2004,10(3):595-604.

［40］Macri D, Mullet E. Risk Communications: around the World Crossnational Validation of An Eightfactor Model of Societal Risk Perception［J］. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2007,13(6):352-1358.

［41］Power M, McCarty L S. Trends in the Development of Ecological Risk Assessment and Management Frameworks ［J］. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2002,8(1):7-18.

［42］Wireman J R, Hooper M J, Porter R C. Ecological Risk Assessment Within the U S Department of Defense［J］. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2003,9(6):1561-1579.

［43］Landis W G, Wiegers J A. Design Considerations and A Suggested Approach for Regional and Comparative Ecological Risk Assessment［J］. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,1997,3(3):287-297.

［44］Landis W G, Wiegers J A. Ten Years of the Relative Risk Model and Regional Scale Ecological Risk Assessment［J］. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2007,13(1):25-38.

［45］Moraes R, Molander S. A Procedure for Ecological Tiered Assessment［J］. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2004,10(2):343-371.

［46］Martin C M, Guvanasen V, Saleem Z A. The 3RMA Risk Assessment Framework: A Flexible Approach for Performing Multimedia, Multipathway, and Multireceptor Risk Assessments under Uncertainty［J］. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2003,9(7):1655-1677.

［47］Burton G A, Chapman P M, Smith E P. Weightof Evidence Approaches for Assessing Ecosystem Impairment ［J］. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2002,8(7):939-972.

［48］Pastorok R A, Akcakaya H R, Regan H, et al. Role of Ecological Modeling in Risk Assessment［J］. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2003,9(4):939-972.

［49］Gaines K F, Porter D E, Dyer S A. Using Wildlife as Receptor Species: A Landscape Approach to Ecological Risk Assessment［J］. Environmental Management,2004,34(4):528-545.

［50］Lu H Y, Axe L, Tyson T A. Development and Application of Computer Simulation Tools for Ecological Risk Assessment［J］. Environmental Modeling and Assessment,2003,8(4):311-322.

［51］Zhao Q Y. Software Review of Toxtools for Windows［J］. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2004,10(3): 609-614.

［52］Chapman P M. Future Ecological Risk Assessment: “Status Human”, Man as the Measure［J］. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2007,13(4):702-712.

［53］Hope B K. What’s Wrong with Risk Assessment? ［J］.Human and Ecological Risk Assessment,2007,13(6):1159-1163.

［54］Landis W G. The Frontiers in Ecological Risk Assessment at Expanding Spatial and Temporal Scales［J］. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment, 2003, 9(6): 1415-1424.

［55］Wickwire W T, Menzie C A. New Approaches in Ecological Risk Assessment: Expanding Scales, Increasing Realism, and Enhancing Causal Analysis［J］. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment, 2003, 9(6):1411-1414.

［56］Vermeire T, Munns W R, Sekizawa J. An Assessment of Integrated Risk Assessement［J］. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment, 2007, 13(2): 339-354.

基金

国家科技支撑计划项目 (2006BAD20B07)；科技部创新方法课题(2007FY140800-1)；北京市自然科学基金项目(8062018)

PDF(758 KB)

49

Accesses

0

Citation

Detail
段落导航
相关文章

/

〈 〉